Tooth-Colored Composite Fillings vs. Silver Amalgam: Choosing the Best Cavity Filling in Indianapolis

Close-up of natural teeth restored with tooth-colored composite fillings in Indianapolis

If you have been told you have a cavity, one of the first questions you may have is what type of filling you will get. For decades, silver-colored amalgam fillings were the standard. Today, many patients and dentists prefer tooth-colored composite fillings. At Tenth Street Family Dental in Indianapolis, we primarily use natural-looking composite fillings and explain all your options so you can make an informed decision.

Close-up of natural teeth restored with tooth-colored composite fillings in Indianapolis

What Are Amalgam Fillings?

Amalgam fillings are made from a mixture of metals, including silver, tin, copper, and mercury bound into a stable alloy. They are strong, durable, and have been used for more than a century. However, they are dark in color, require more of the healthy tooth to be removed to hold them in place, and can expand and contract with temperature changes over time, which may contribute to cracks in the surrounding tooth.

What Are Composite Fillings?

Composite fillings are made of a tooth-colored resin mixed with fine glass or ceramic particles. The material is applied in layers, shaped to match your natural tooth, and hardened with a special curing light. Because composite bonds directly to the tooth, it can support the remaining structure and seal the area well.

Comparing Your Options

  • Appearance: Composite blends with your teeth and is virtually invisible. Amalgam is noticeably dark.
  • Tooth preservation: Composite usually requires removing less healthy tooth structure.
  • Bonding: Composite bonds to the tooth; amalgam is held mechanically.
  • Durability: Both are durable. Amalgam may last longer in very large, high-pressure areas, but modern composites perform very well in most situations.
  • Sensitivity: Some patients notice brief sensitivity after either type.
  • Versatility: Composite can also repair chipped, cracked, or worn teeth.

Are Silver Fillings Safe?

Major health organizations consider existing amalgam fillings safe for most people, and there is generally no need to remove intact silver fillings just because they contain mercury. In 2020, the FDA recommended that certain higher-risk groups, such as pregnant women, nursing mothers, young children, and people with certain health conditions, consider alternatives when possible. If an old amalgam filling is cracked, leaking, or has decay underneath, we can replace it with composite or an inlay or onlay.

When Might a Different Restoration Be Better?

For very large cavities or teeth with significant damage, a filling alone may not be strong enough. An onlay or porcelain crown may be recommended to protect the tooth from breaking. If decay reaches the nerve, root canal therapy may be needed first.

What to Expect During a Filling

  1. We numb the area, or use a laser for some cavities with little or no numbing.
  2. Decay is removed and the tooth is cleaned.
  3. Composite is applied in thin layers and hardened.
  4. The filling is shaped and polished, and your bite is checked.

You can typically eat right away once numbness wears off.

Making Your Fillings Last

Brush twice daily with fluoride toothpaste, floss every day, limit sugary snacks and drinks, avoid chewing ice or hard candy, and keep your six-month checkups. If you grind your teeth, a nightguard can help protect fillings. Regular exams with digital X-rays help us spot worn or leaking fillings before they cause problems.

Cavity Care in Central Indiana

We treat cavities for patients from Irvington, Lawrence, Warren Township, and Beech Grove in Marion County, Fishers, Carmel, and Noblesville in Hamilton County, Greenfield and McCordsville in Hancock County, and Avon in Hendricks County. If you are searching for tooth-colored fillings near me or the best dentist in Indianapolis, we are glad to help.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do composite fillings last?

With good care, composite fillings often last many years.

Does insurance cover tooth-colored fillings?

Most plans cover fillings; some may cover composite on back teeth at the amalgam rate. We will explain your costs.

Should I replace all my silver fillings?

Not necessarily. We usually recommend replacing them only if they are damaged or failing.

Ready to take the next step? Contact Tenth Street Family Dental to schedule your filling appointment. We are located in the Smart and Final shopping center at 6919 E. 10th Street, Suite A1, Indianapolis, IN 46219, and are open Monday–Friday 9 AM–5 PM and Saturday 9 AM–2 PM. We welcome most insurance plans, Medicaid, and Medicare Advantage patients.